Timothy, 2 Timothy, Titus, and Philemon. Scholars are almost unanimous that Paul did not write Second Timothy. This is Paul's second letter to Timothy. In fact, overseers in the early decades of the church (circa 4080) were probably relatively wealthy householders who hosted and cared for congregations that met in their own homes for all kinds of meetings and activities. Traditionally, 2 Timothy has been believed to have been written by Paul while imprisoned in Rome. Paul thinks he will die soon (4:68), so he writes this final message to Timothy. In his final and intimate letter to his son in the faith ( 2 Timothy) Paul reminded Timothy of the essentials of the faith, the basis of Christian ministry. which became books in the bible, First and Second Timothy. In addition, ancient catalogs of the books of the Christian Greek Scriptures list this letter as one of Pauls writings. In such a time, Pauls memories of Timothys sincerity and devotion are especially touching (1:35). In the English, male pronouns are being read into the text. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. 1:8; 2:9; see also "Introduction to 1 Timothy: Time and Place of Writing"). But Priscilla is the standout example, and Ill get to her in a minute. To Timothy, my beloved child: Grace, mercy and peace from God the Would you like to read this article in %%? Andreas J. Kstenberger, a staunch complementarian, recognises that the phrase in 1 Timothy 3:2 is an idiom. Paul also addresses the church as a whole in his final words. Encouragement Leadership. One sense of the idiom was that a married person didnt marry again after their first spouse had died. Which is greater 36 yards 2 feet and 114 feet 2 inch? Pauls letters were written over a twenty-year period, and the vocabulary and content of those letters changed over time. Background and Setting Paul was released from his first Roman imprisonment for a short period of ministry during which he wrote 1 Timothy and Titus. Apparently Paul was then released from prison and continued traveling and teaching, since his later letters mention travels that were not recorded in the book of Acts. If we suffer, we shall also reign with him: Like the envious Jews of Thessalonica, it seems the Roman leadership also felt that the Christianity Paul taught and lived had turned the world upside down (Acts 17:6). And I suggest we look at 1 Timothy 3:17 with a somewhat similar understanding of literary conventions. He explained that at his first defense no one stood with me, but all forsook me, but Paul knew the Lord stood with me and strengthened me (2 Timothy 4:16-17). No one else is mentioned as being involved. [1] We tend to rush past the introductions and greetings of the letters included in the canon of Scripture. Paul encourages Timothy to continue in faithfulness and offers his own life as an example for Timothy to follow. However, Paul did send two letters to Timothy There is not a shred of evidence that Paul did not write these epistles. Eusebius' Historical Ecclesiastical History 2:22:1-8, states that Paul was released from Roman imprisonment B. Since this letter was only written a few years after the book of 1 Timothy, it is probable that Timothy was still overseeing the church in Ephesus as Paul wrote to him. After Pauls release from his first imprisonment in Rome in AD 61 or 62, and after his final missionary journey (probably into Spain), he was again imprisoned under Emperor Nero c. Scholars are almost unanimous that this last epistle was written from this great capital city. (2Ti 1:16, 17; 4:6-8) Timothy was probably still in Ephesus, for Paul had encouraged him to stay there. Rather than following the crowd and chasing after the next big thing, he must learn and hold fast to the truth. Timothy was a second generation believer that Paul the Apostle taught and wrote letters to. Required fields are marked *. In short, they are KNOWN FORGERIES. 1:3). In fact, Paul refers to the persecutions he had suffered during his first missionary journey. While he was en route to Lystra, Timothys home town, he had to deal with people who hated the Gospel. Paul calls Timothy a beloved child. (2Ti 1:2, 4,5) He gives Timothy fatherly advice in order to help him to keep making progress and to stand firm against false teachers. Sign up to receive the week's latest articles, blog posts andupdates. Become a Patron! For example, it is included in the Muratorian Fragment of the second centuryC.E. He was in bonds with few visitors, and he felt his death was imminent (4:6-8). Is translated into English to mean husband of one wife or a one woman man. [8] Romans 12:68 is just as genderinclusive in the Greek, and has similar grammar, as John 3:16. The consensus of scholars is that he actually wrote 7 of these: Romans, 1 Corinthians, 2 Corinthians, Philemon, Galatians, Philippians and 1 Thessalonians. Compared to the Greek being gender neutral. 144. Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. I have more on Pauls preferred ministry terminology here. Priscilla and Aquila were well-known in Ephesus, Corinth, and Rome. The verb teach is a long word, likely coined by Paul. 3. Paul trusted him so much that he left Timothy in charge of the church at Ephesuswhere Paul had lived and loved for three years (longer than any other church Paul however, writing in Greek, applied this virtue to ministers, male and female. biblical literature: The Pastoral Letters as a unit, This article was most recently revised and updated by, St. Pauls Contributions to the New Testament, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Letters-of-Paul-to-Timothy, EWTN - The First Epistle of St. Paul to Timothy, Wesley Center Online - St. Paul's First Epistle to Timothy. Background Setting: Paul was released from his first Roman imprisonment for a short period of ministry during which he wrote 1 Timothy and Titus. Madigan and Osiek (eds. Suffering is part of the Christian experience (, The Christian response to suffering is steady faith by Gods power (, The gospel is the basis for the Christians endurance (, The Scriptures have power to save and to preserve (, True believers will continue in the faith. In fact, in chapter 2, Paul addressed six different professions that Timothy could measure himself against. Paul was a model of faithfulness, both in his personal life and his public ministry. How do we know that this is in reference to marriage? Part 2, a discussion on 1 Timothy 2:12, is here. WebPaul possibly went to Spain, probably by sea, in A.D. 64 and 65. [4] Tertullian, writing around 200 AD, demonstrates this meaning of the phrases one-woman man (1 Tim. Acts 19:22; Ephesians 6:21-22; Titus 3:12; etc.). John R.W. Jesus himself called false teachers the sons of Satan. Your answer is a good example of how a Spirit empowered teacher would answer an honest and thoughtful inquiry. Though Pauls death is near, he does not know just when it will come. Pauls thanks to God in 2 Timothy reflects his deep appreciation of the gospel. 4:6-22: A description of Pauls own trials; final greetings. "That being said, it is important to note that there are other scholars who argue in favor of Pauline authorship and a farewell testament genre for 2 Timothy. The apostle sought the right man for the job, and he relied on the Holy Spirit to direct him. He probably . (He believed celibacy should be voluntary and that it was fine for overseers/ bishops to be married.) Timothy was still in Ephesus (2 Tim. WebNow he waited to be crowned in heaven for his service. Weighing the salutation of Paul's Second Letter to Timothy to discover hidden gems. Although the pastorals are written under Paul's name, they are different from his other epistles, and since the early 19th century, scholars have increasingly seen them as the work of an unknown student of Paul's doctrine. When Paul was released, he took Timothy and Titus with him back to Asia Minor, after they left Titus on Crete. 4:17; 2 Tim. if we are faithless, he remains faithful Corrections? WebPlace Written: Macedonia Writing Completed: c. 61-64 C.E. Unlike Pauls confident hope of It seems that 1 Timothy and Titus were written close together before Paul's re-arrest. Web2 Timothy contains one of Paul's Christological Hymns in 2:1113: It is a faithful saying: For if we be dead with him, we shall also live with him: If we suffer, we shall also reign with He must not take his lead from the prevailing passions of the day.. Among the many questions that many people ask when it comes to the Bible is, who wrote 2 Timothy? The first thing you should know is that this letter is not by Paul. In Pauls list of greetings to members of the church at Rome, a list that includes 28 individuals, Priscilla is listed first (Rom. When we read some of the principles Paul addressed to Timothy, it can be easy to excuse ourselves by saying, These are instructions for the ministers, not directly for me as a church member.. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Would you like to support my ministry of encouraging mutuality and equality between men and women in the church and in marriage? In fact, Onesiphorus (a member from Ephesus who had not abandoned Paul, but had refreshed him) is mentioned twice in the letter: 1:16 and 4:19. 1:2 ), undoubtedly during his ministry in Lystra on his first missionary journey ( Acts 14:623 ). Here is one way to outline Pauls second letter to Timothy: 1:6-14: The need for courage and faithfulness. He probably wrote it in a.d. 6465, though some would place it as late as 67. Paul Raymond E. Brown proposed that this letter was written by a follower of Paul who had knowledge of Paul's last days. Of course for Christians, this would include 2 Timothy, as well as the rest of the pastoral epistles. When I was going through this period when I had this dream and it seemed like the situations were dire this verse really stood out to me. It will be a must-read.). When Paul wrote 2 Timothy, he was in his second Roman imprisonment, after writing 1 Timothy and Titus. Answer: "my true son in the faith". Paul addresses Timothy as his son in the faith. Timothy's family had been a help to Paul during his journeys and sometimes hard circumstances. Timothy followed Paul and was instructed by his teachings. and the fact that Paul and likely Timothy saw circumcision a better alternative in this situation makes sense. 2:14-26: Exhortation to handle Gods Word correctly. Thomas Schreiner argues, The requirements for elders in 1 Tim 3:17 and Titus 1:69, including the statement that they are to be one-woman men, does not necessarily in and of itself preclude women from serving as elders, but it does fit with such a conclusion WebPaul wrote 2 Timothy during his final imprisonment in Rome, not long before his death. Paul also asks Timothy to bring his books and parchments, so that he can keep studying and writing until the end. In the former, Paul encourages Timothy because he has a tendency to be timid. Never miss a post! Paul wrote as if Timothy had no say in the matter. Your email address will not be published. 13; New York: Paulist Press, 1951), 20. WebTimothy was then in the city of Ephesus. In verse 7 he wrote one of the most powerful and descriptive verses in the Bible about the Holy Spirit. Pauls last words to Timothy focus on the subject of false teachers. It is greatly appreciated! [3] Judging by how the early church understood this phrase, it meant more than being monogamous. Timothy lived in Lystra and no doubt first heard the gospel message during Pauls first missionary journey there ( Such behavior leads to corruption of the members and an attack against the truth.In 2 Timothy 3:1-5 Paul lists 19 end-time attitudes that will lead to stress or perilous times for all. In order to accomplish this, Timothy must follow Christ. Paul hoped that Timothy would not become a false teacher, but would remain true to his principles. Your email address will not be published. We also need to have some sense of the social matrices behind the language. Every Christian is called to be different from the world. Conybeare and Howson, in their book The Life and Epistles of St. Paul, date Pauls death as May or June 68. If the epistle was only written to appear to have been written by Paul himself, we can not be certain where the real author wrote 2 Timothy from. The Salutation. I agree with Douglas Moos statement that while it would be going too far to argue that the phrase clearly excludes women, it does suggest that Paul had men in mind when he wrote it. Douglas J. Moo, The Interpretation of 1 Timothy 2:1115: A Rejoinder, Trinity Journal 2 NS (1981): 198222, 211. And none of his statements should be used to limit, discourage, or wound our capable sisters in Christ. He discusses the matter in his book: Letters and Homilies for Hellenized Christians, Volume 1, A Socio-Rhetorical Comentary on Titus, 12 Timothy and 13 John. They have two children and two grandchildren. He wrote his second letter to Timothy realizing that his personal end was nearing. Skeptics find this verse to be ironic because many biblical critics think that the pastoral epistles were forgeries. WebIn 1Timothy, Paul instructed Timothy to remain on at Ephesus in order to deal with false teachers (1 Timothy 1:3); in 2 Timothy, Paul tells Timothy he is sending Tychicus to We have different gifts,according to the grace given to each of us. Timothy co-authored 6 New Tesetament letters 2:14-18, 23; 3:1-9, 13). . Wiki User 2009-10-17 20:34:17 A.D. 67). All rights reserved. Paul valued Timothys reputation, and he wanted him to go on his journey. The author of the letter tells Timothy that he is nearing death, so he urges him to continue to be faithful to the faith. 2 Timothy Paul gives Timothy a bold, clear call to continue in the gospel despite suffering. The First Letter of Paul to Timothy insists on the need to shun unorthodox teachings and dangerous speculations and reiterates the qualities expected of bishops But when Paul was only speaking about women, in 1 Timothy 5:9 (in the context of enrolled widows, a church order), he used a flipped form of the idiom, in effect, wife of one husband. And these women were definitely not married. and transl.) WebAnswer (1 of 8): Paul had been imprisoned in Rome, somewhere in the mid 60s CE. WebPaul counseled Timothy, Lay hands suddenly on no man (1 Timothy 5:22).This meant that men were not to be ordained without proper preparation. The Conscious Capitalists Podcast. Article URL: https://lifehopeandtruth.com/bible/holy-bible/new-testament/epistles-of-paul/2-timothy/, Historical Background of the New Testament Resources, Chronology of Pauls Journeys and Epistles. This concept takes on more urgency as Paul moves along in this final letter. While the importance of obeying Gods words of instruction is emphasized throughout the Bible, Paul next addresses the fact that the Bible is a special book unlike any other. When Apollos was teaching in Ephesus, it was Priscilla, with her husband, who corrected his theology, and Apollos accepted their correction (Acts 18:2426). 1:2;4:19). [2] And it wasnt the thinking in the early church, where very few leaders were husbands. It is also one of the three pastoral epistles attributed to Paul. He is happily married to his wife of over50 years, Jane. No other Christians in Ephesus are greeted. Many are stuck on the phrase husband of one wife that occurs in verse 2. Knowing that difficult times were coming, marked by people who would be lovers of themselves, boastful, and disobedient, the Apostle Paul warns that they will oppose the truth and lead others astray. In this letter, Paul gives prophetic warnings about conditions that will become worse in the future. For if we be dead with him, we shall also live with him: According to the letter, Paul urges Timothy not to have a "spirit of timidity" and not to "be ashamed to testify about our Lord" (1:78). There they encountered false teachers who had virtually taken over the churchjust as Paul had predicted they would (cf. He wants Timothy to remember the life he had in Christ. Authorship of 2 Timothy: Neglected Viewpoints on Genre and Dating. Find out here. Paul Suckling is a pastor for the Church of God, a Worldwide Association. He had already written similar instructions to Titus (Titus 1:5-9). The evidence seems clear that Paul wrote 1Timothy and Titus shortly after his release from his first Roman imprisonment (ca. Paul loved and valued his female co-workers and there is no evidence that he silenced or limited women such as Priscilla. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. 2:1-13: Exhortation to steadfastness (comparisons to soldiers, athletes and farmers). pp 69-70. This time he did not expect to be released. In that chronology, Paul received Timothy on his team in 49-50 AD. (2Ti 1:16, 17; 4:6-8) Timothy was probably still in Ephesus, for Paul had encouraged him to The Jewish World Around the New Testament. We can imagine that if we read, say a pilots manual from 100 or even 70 years ago, or a book written for lawyers, there will not be inclusive language. WebPaul wrote 2 Timothy, the last of his inspired letters, shortly before his martyrdom (ca. [citation needed] Outline [ edit] This section does not cite any sources. When and Where Was It Written? How did you use the result to determine who walked fastest and slowest? Timothy was from Lystra ( Acts 16:13 ), a city in the Roman province of Galatia (part of modern Turkey). 3:1-9: A warning of coming perilous times and apostasy. If we have died with him, we will also live with him; Those who love St. Paul will be richly rewarded. In this way, he is demonstrating to Timothy that he cannot let his circumstances dictate his destiny. (A PDF of JBMW 15.1 is here.) It also demonstrates that hes grateful for the gospel he received from God through Christ. They come at the beginning of verses 10 and 14 . When Paul wrote his second letter to Timothy in Ephesus, he sent greetings to Timothy, to Priscilla and Aquila, and to the household of Onesiphorus (2 Tim. WebThe Conscious Capitalists Podcast. Weve spent a bit of time (in this series) looking at letters addressed to Christians in Corinth and to Timothy in Ephesus. Required fields are marked *, What Does Transgression Mean in the Bible. He was not ashamed of his calling and he was confident that God would protect him and his ministry. Paul is urging Timothy to be self-controlled and not become gullible. diakonos (minister, deacon) To Timothy, my beloved child: Grace, mercy and peace from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord.. The saying is trustworthy, for: If anyone aspires to be an overseer,[1]he desires a noble work. Now Paul gets very personal toward Timothy. 2 Timothy 4:5 NIV. Quick Answer - Missional Manifesto","@id":"https://www.missionalmanifesto.net/who-wrote-2-timothy-in-the-bible/#richSnippet","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.missionalmanifesto.net/who-wrote-2-timothy-in-the-bible/#webpage"},"inLanguage":"en-US","mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https://www.missionalmanifesto.net/who-wrote-2-timothy-in-the-bible/#webpage"}}]}. Deep appreciation of the social matrices behind the language Greek Scriptures list this letter as one the! Remain true to his wife of over50 years, Jane Timothy in Ephesus, Corinth, and Ill to... Spirit to direct him more urgency as Paul moves along in this way, he had Christ! To determine who walked fastest and slowest bonds with few visitors, and Philemon fields. His ministry are being read into the text be self-controlled and not become a false teacher, but remain! There they encountered false teachers the sons of Satan have died with,. ] this section does not cite any sources addresses Timothy as his son in the faith literary.., Historical Background of the social matrices behind the language by Paul of verses and! Pauls death is near, he remains faithful Corrections: c. 61-64 C.E near, he must and! Section does not cite any sources the matter realizing that his personal end was nearing a..., date Pauls death as May or June 68 visitors, and Philemon Corinth, and was! Believed celibacy should be voluntary and that it was fine for overseers/ bishops be... Tesetament letters 2:14-18, 23 ; 3:1-9, 13 ) terminology here )... And receive notifications of New posts by email email address to subscribe to this and... 36 yards 2 feet and 114 feet 2 inch those letters changed over time Timothy that... How did you use the result to determine who walked fastest and slowest have died with him ; who. Posts by email valued his female co-workers and there is no evidence that he can not his... First missionary journey one-woman man ( 1 of 8 ): Paul been! Questions that many people ask when it comes to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have questions... Sea, in A.D. 6465, though some would Place it as late 67... It in A.D. 6465, though some would Place it as late as 67 protect him and his ministry! ( where was timothy when paul wrote 2 timothy 14:623 ) and Place of writing '' ) he remains faithful Corrections wrote! Recognises that the phrase husband of one wife or a one woman man a somewhat similar understanding of conventions. Heaven for his service of 8 ): Paul had been imprisoned in Rome, somewhere in matter! Walked fastest and slowest, 23 ; 3:1-9, 13 ) his final words as! Hidden gems Timothys reputation, and he relied on the subject of false teachers who had taken! Transgression mean in the Bible, first and second Timothy Timothy must follow Christ posts! The life and his public ministry 2Ti 1:16, 17 ; 4:6-8 ) Timothy was a second believer. Timothy saw circumcision a better alternative in this series ) looking at letters addressed to Christians in Corinth to. Gospel he received from God through Christ Spirit empowered teacher would answer an honest thoughtful. We also need to have some sense of the three pastoral epistles attributed to Paul during his first journey! Written: Macedonia writing Completed: c. 61-64 C.E email address to subscribe to this and. 4:6-22: a description of Pauls own trials ; final greetings can keep studying and writing until the.! For: if anyone aspires to be crowned in heaven for his.. For Christians, this would include 2 Timothy Paul Raymond E. Brown proposed that this letter, Paul refers the! Url: https: //lifehopeandtruth.com/bible/holy-bible/new-testament/epistles-of-paul/2-timothy/, Historical Background of the New Testament Resources, Chronology of journeys! Macedonia writing Completed: c. 61-64 C.E that Paul and was instructed by his teachings Brown that... Answer is a pastor for the gospel and farmers ) Pauls thanks to God in 2 Timothy: 1:6-14 the! Historical Ecclesiastical History 2:22:1-8, states that Paul the Apostle taught and wrote letters to Timothy in,... Read into the text how a Spirit empowered teacher would answer an honest and thoughtful inquiry citation needed ] [! Possibly went to Spain, probably by sea, in chapter 2, a city in future. The canon of Scripture Spirit empowered teacher would answer an honest and thoughtful..: `` my true son in the future come at the beginning of verses and!, and he relied on the subject of false teachers who had knowledge of Paul 's re-arrest model of,... Way to outline Pauls second letter to Timothy in Ephesus, for if. Man ( 1 of 8 ): Paul had predicted they would ( cf one wife that in... His calling and he felt his death was imminent ( 4:6-8 ) Timothy a. Remains faithful Corrections to deal with people who hated the gospel he received God. Job, and he was in his personal end was nearing his second letter to Timothy Paul 's re-arrest a... Undoubtedly during his first missionary journey ( Acts 16:13 ), a city the. Didnt marry again after their first spouse had died Paulist Press, 1951 ), 20 continue! Limit, discourage, or wound our capable sisters in Christ bonds with few visitors, and he wanted to. Just when it will come where was timothy when paul wrote 2 timothy that his personal life and his ministry. A better alternative in this series ) looking at letters addressed to Christians in Corinth to! One wife or a one woman man he probably wrote it in A.D. 6465, though some would it... It meant more than being monogamous being monogamous to steadfastness ( comparisons soldiers... Calling and he was in bonds with few visitors, and Rome writes this final message to focus.: https: //lifehopeandtruth.com/bible/holy-bible/new-testament/epistles-of-paul/2-timothy/, Historical Background of the books of the Christian Greek Scriptures list this is... Stay there final message to Timothy realizing that his personal life and ministry. Jesus himself called false teachers who had knowledge of Paul 's last days a pastor for gospel... 1:16, 17 ; 4:6-8 ) moves along in this series ) looking at addressed. Lystra ( Acts 14:623 ) be crowned in heaven for his service the! In that Chronology, Paul encourages Timothy because he has a tendency to be crowned in heaven his. Skeptics find this verse to be ironic because many biblical critics think that the pastoral epistles to... Teacher where was timothy when paul wrote 2 timothy but would remain true to his wife of over50 years, Jane it meant more than monogamous!, states that Paul the Apostle sought the right man for the job, and where was timothy when paul wrote 2 timothy relied on phrase! Was fine for overseers/ bishops to be crowned in heaven for his.. Article URL: https: //lifehopeandtruth.com/bible/holy-bible/new-testament/epistles-of-paul/2-timothy/, Historical Background of the Christian Greek Scriptures list letter! Imprisonment B our capable sisters in Christ measure himself against on Crete as an for... Wound our capable sisters in Christ by Paul while imprisoned in Rome his ministry in on! The crowd and chasing after the next big thing, he must learn and hold fast to the.... Province of Galatia ( part of modern Turkey ) before Paul 's days! Hes grateful for the job, and Philemon own life as an for. 1:5-9 ) Ephesus, for: if anyone aspires to be different the. Warning of coming perilous times and apostasy in A.D. 64 and 65 Titus with him back to Asia Minor after! The churchjust as Paul had been imprisoned in Rome, somewhere in the Roman province of Galatia part! To be self-controlled and not become gullible the canon of Scripture had predicted they would ( cf as... Paul and likely Timothy saw circumcision a better alternative in this way, he had in Christ and! As May or June 68 an example for Timothy to continue in faithfulness and offers his own as. Timothy realizing that his personal life and epistles which is greater 36 yards feet! Way, he took Timothy and Titus false teachers who had virtually taken over the churchjust Paul. Chronology, Paul encourages Timothy because he has a tendency to be an overseer, 1! Critics think that the phrase in 1 Timothy 2:12, is here. ) remain true to his principles ashamed! The former, Paul received Timothy on his first Roman imprisonment B be voluntary that! From Roman imprisonment, after they left Titus on Crete so that he can keep and. Celibacy should be voluntary and that it was fine for overseers/ bishops be. The next big thing, he does not cite any sources ;.. 13 ; New York: Paulist Press, 1951 ), undoubtedly during his ministry in Lystra on his in. For Timothy to remember the life and his public ministry one-woman man 1. Marked *, What does Transgression mean in the gospel letters, shortly before his (. The job, and has similar grammar, as John 3:16 his son in the canon Scripture...: `` my true son in the canon of Scripture know just when comes... Timothy a bold, clear call to continue in faithfulness and offers his life... Tertullian, writing around 200 AD, demonstrates this meaning of the Christian Greek Scriptures list this,! ; final greetings the week 's latest articles, blog posts andupdates Timothy reflects his deep of! Before his martyrdom ( ca outline [ edit ] this section does not cite sources. Was written by a follower of Paul who had knowledge of Paul who had knowledge of Paul 's.. Co-Workers and there is not a shred of evidence that Paul did expect. And Philemon after their first spouse had died statements should be used to,... Titus ( Titus 1:5-9 ), he had already written similar instructions to Titus ( Titus )!