(Sushi we will eat raw, but it's certainly not alive) So the difference is the fact that she's eating sea creatures that are alive. She also provides subtitles for her videos in usually over 10 different languages, making them accessible to a broad audience. She launched her channel in November 2018 where she initially made ASMR videos along with food, before making videos strictly about seafood, deserts, and hot Cheetos. As complicated and controversial a process this may be, it is an essential part of all platforms (Gillespie, 2018). Both just because of the way the food is eaten and because how she is treating the animals. On March 26th, 2020, YouTuber[8] Cr1tikal posted a video titled "Youtuber Tortures and Eats Animals Alive" about Ssoyoung in which he criticized her and accused her of animal cruelty. Ssoyoung has become popular due to ASMR videos. Msg/data rates may apply. Korean mukbang is when influencers post videos of themselves eating a large amount of food. On the YouTube channel "Ssoyoung" she shows graphic videos of her torturing innocent fish, crustaceans and other sea life on camera. How the YouTube Algorithm Works (Or Why Your Videos Arent Getting Views). He said that he had eaten the animal's ear as a "snack". YouTubes community guidelines clearly state that violent or graphic content is not allowed on the platform which includes Content where there is infliction of unnecessary suffering or harm deliberately causing an animal distress. Some restaurants steam octopuses, lobsters, and other animals alive in live seafood hot pots. It has also been found not to encourage animal abuse. Center for Animal Law Studies - Lewis & Clark. There have also been several complaints about YouTubes manual review system, and the apparent inconsistency of their decisions. The South Korean ASMR YouTuber known as Ssoyoung is facing backlash due to a video where she is seen ingesting a live octopus, with viewers accusing her of animal abuse. She is famous for her 'mukbang' videos, in which she prepares large amounts of food and eats them in front of the camera. We never considered the impact of these actions on the animals involved. Critics say Korean YouTuber "Ssoyoung" has taken her viral "ASMR mukbang" videos too far, posting distressing footage for her 3.4million subscribers. Ssoyoung made her acting debut in 2003. She allegedly claimed that she doesnt know why shes not more popular. YouTube is hardly to blame for peoples preconceived notions of which animals can orcannot be tortured. A YOUTUBE star has sparked outrage over videos of her abusing and then eating animals alive. 10.8K Likes, 65 Comments. Could you tell the difference between this plant-based egg and a Meet the sailing robots trying to solve climate change, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. She is 36 years old as of 2023 and she is married. Korean cuisine is very different from what manypeople, at least in the western world, consider normal. Though one could argue that it is part of the culture there. A plate is typically held over the bowl to prevent the shrimp from leaping out as they are much more active than when served as Odori ebi. While she's pouring soy sauce over live squids whose hoods have been cut off, she's getting tens of millions of views. Imagine being pulled from a tank, flung onto a table, and pinned down as your arms and legs are cut off. The issue with many people take with Ssoyoung's videos relates to what she is eating. If you don't believe me, . YouTuber Ssoyoung who [astonishingly] has 3.4 million subscribers has been blasted for her videos where she consumes LIVE animals. A video of her eating a large piece of Cheetos cheese was seen by millions of people. Ssoyoungs content as well as her channel, not considering the animal cruelty, appears to perfectly cater to these points. There are three main difficulties Gillespie (2018) presents in his book, all of which can be seen at play in the controversy surrounding Ssoyoung. Covington, P., Adams, J. In September 2016, PETA went inside restaurants in Los Angeles that mutilate and serve live animals. They also debate the role the videos play, if any, in Asian culture. She takes them out of the water while they are still alive and pinches and beats them to get a 'funny' reaction from the fish, herself and her deranged audience. Her name is Ssoyoung and what she does on her channel is she buys sea creatures alive and then kills them in the slowest, most inhumane ways possible because she likes to watch them squirm around and then post Facebook royalty-free music behind it as a joke. Ssoyoung is one of the most controversial ASMR YouTubers right now. TikTok video from Ssoyoung Fans (@ssoyoungontiktok): "Eating Giant Hot Cheese Stick Green onion kimchi with #ssoyoung #eatwithssoyoung #eatingshow #mukbang #video #asmrsounds #foodtiktok #foryou #trend #trending". Google, which owns YouTube, has a similar policy with an exception that the food has to be. Octopusesareso intelligent that theyre sometimes referred to as primates of the sea.You may rememberInky, an octopus at the National Aquarium of New Zealand, who made international headlines in April 2016 after heclimbed out of a tank, traversed the aquarium floor, and slid down a 164-foot pipe to freedom. Ssoyoungs real name is Han Soo Young (In Korean: ) born on January 1, 1987, and is better known online as Ssoyoung. She also ate raw fish and shrimp. Blanket octopusessnatch poisonous tentacles from the Portuguese man o war and wield them like swords. However, a group of Google engineers published a paper in 2016 which showed their plans for how the YouTube recommendation engine could be used to improve user experience, and with that, get more engagement on their platform. A man named Antnio Pinto bought a donkey for three thousand cruzeiros. Men like to see women acting like children. On his show Man vs. Wild, host Bear Grylls is sometimes shown eating various insects alive. Kitchen staff explained that she would be kept alive until another customer ordered the remaining limbs. YouTubes guidelines clearly state that videos featuring animal cruelty are not allowed on their website. . There have been calls to ban eating animals alive on these shows. Much like with challenge and prank videos, the Mukbang genre is flooded with content creators trying to find an audience which lead to increasingly shocking videos, with some turning to drama and others turning to eating hyper-realistic foods. Oftentimes, her reactions to their flailing tentacles and writhing bodies. & Sargin, E. (2016). Get texts & occasional phone calls for Action Alerts, local events, & other updates to help animals with PETA! This was considered funny in her videos and was criticized. Were calling on lawmakers to introduce legislation that prohibits animals from being mutilated, prepared, and served alive. [18], Sea urchins are prized as a delicacy in many places worldwide (particularly in Japan, France, South Korea, Chile, New Zealand, the Philippines, Italy, Spain, the Mediterranean,[19] and North America)[20] for their briny-flavoured gonads. Blanket octopuses snatch poisonous tentacles from the Portuguese man o war and wield them like swords. ", Comment if you know any other news about Ssoyoung ASMR~. This help content & information General Help Center experience. The octopus gets killed and chopped up right before serving so nerve-activity in the tentacles makes it keep moving after having been killed. Though Ssoyoung ASMR didnt reveal her husbands identity or any photo of him. traditional or standard purposes such as hunting or food preparation, Newsweek reported. Lobsters tails are also torn off, prepared sashimi style, and plated right next to their mutilated but still-living bodies, for the amusement of patrons. Now, with over 300,000,000 views on her channel, surely someone knows that this is wrong. She recently commented on all of her videos addressing this issue, so I decided to make a video about it. In fact, Newsweek argues that purposefully gross-out videos provid[e] fodder for hate speech towards Asian people and cultures.. 's net worth estimates estimate Ssoyoung's net worth at nearly $6.49 million. Christine Ha a winner of the show MasterChef and executive chef of Houston-based Vietnamese restaurant The Blind Goat told Newsweek there is a fine line to tread between content on cultural food customs and exploitation of animals for clicks. Facebook, which owns Instagram, does not allow violence against animals unless it happens in certain contexts like consuming or preparing food. Januar). In a 2015 report on Vice titled 'How An Octopus Feels When It's Eaten Alive', Hilary Pollack wrote: "The designations of welfare, cruelty, and simple squeamishness are not always clear-cut -- especially in issues surrounding the types of animals that we don't hold particularly near and dear. Eating live marine animals is widespread in Korea, [] but I wouldnt call this Korean culture, because I believe culture is something that you want to respect and you respect and believe in values and customs that reflect Korean society, she added. Live squids after having their mantle cut off and their eyes exposed Sea creatures are often not considered to be as much of a living being as other animals. He bit off the animal's ear and carried it around with him as he ran around his neighbourhood in his underwear, covered in blood, before he was restrained by police. Journal of Experimental Biology, 218(7), 967976. Another question we hear often is: How much is Ssoyoung worth or how much does Ssoyoung ASMR earn? 5.8K Likes, TikTok video from Ssoyoung Fans (@ssoyoungontiktok): "Cheese Pizza Honey Butter Almond BTS Lemona Eating with #ssoyoung #eatwithssoyoung #eatingshow #mukbang #video #asmrsounds #foodtiktok #foryou #trend #trending". However, YouTube has gotten increasingly under fire by people calling them out for seemingly moderating content more so in favor of profit margins than to keep the platform enjoyable and safe for its viewers and content creators. She is a horrible human who needs to be stopped. YouTube/Ssoyoung A YouTuber with 3.4 million followers has been widely condemned for a video which shows her eating live squid and octopus. Her videos are also usually very long, usually lasting for 10 to 20 minutes, which further increases Watch time. Sir_Sesh_Lord 3 yr. ago I agree with your last point and it's totally correct! Ssoyoung makes $30K a year in salary and is estimated to have a net worth of $6.49 million. SIO ASMR A Mukbanger - Know His Complete Biography and Net Worth, Yummy Hamzy Mukbang An Amazing Mukbanger with Millions of Subscribers, Healthy Breakfast Ideas for Weight Loss (High Protein & Low Calories). From sharks to squid, nothing is safe from her. Ssoyoung is a South Korean mukbang and ASMR vlogger known for her videos in which she kills and consumes fish and other sea animals, including videos in which she eats raw sea animals and even live octopuses. And when looking at the likes and comments under SSoyoungs channel, and the likes on her videos, it appears that the disregard for aquatic animal welfare is still a very normal occurrence among her viewers. Popular as the ASMR Mukbang YouTuber, the 30-year-old has lately received severe backlash with critics calling her 'cruel.' Some YouTubers even demanded YouTube ban her channel. After all, when thinking about animal cruelty, very few think of lobsters being boiled alive. Youtube video of the preparation and eating of sannakji, "Comeu as orelhas do jumento para depois enforca-lo: Loucura", "Comeu as orelhas do jumento e depois enforcou-o com as rdeas", "Comeu as orelhas do jumento e depois enforcou-o com as rdeas: Recife", "It's time to ban eating live creatures on I'm A Celebrity, Get Me Out Of Here", "7 animals that are eaten alive by humans", "Raymond Blanc: 'These little live eels jump from the bowl and down", "Viral video of live frog sashimi sparks protest", "Eating live frogs, rats "cures tummy upsets", "I Ate and Drank Cobra in Vietnam's Snake Village", "Hanoi's most popular snake restaurant beckons adventurous diners", "11 Foods Eaten Alive That May Shock You", "Gordon Ramsay eats beating heart of a snake", "Anthony Bourdain took us on a journey of the world often by eating really strange things", "Clash of culture? Ethan Klein, one half of the husband-wife duo of H3H3. The trend is considerably unhealthy by some critics, but things get controversial when someusers film themselves eating live animals there have been accusations that popular channels, like Ssoyoung, are engaging in animal cruelty. Imagine someone cutting your arm off and pouring salt on your wounds. Or is it the animal that is the problem here? Taking this into consideration, it is hardly surprising that her channel was able to grow so fast in such a short time. These beaches are the best of the best in US, according to Bald eagle rescued after eating rat poison in Massachusetts. The ants are chilled so that they move slowly, and are supposed to taste like lemongrass. As YouTube is an internationally available platform they, just like any other platform, have to take cultural differences into consideration. There is always at least some mention of the food. Does She Torture and Eat Animals Alive, Who is the famous Ssoyoung ASMR? Ssoyoung, who boasts a following of more than three million on her YouTube channel, frequently makes videos involving live animals (especially sea creatures, including octopus). Now, imagine Ssoyoung abusing a dog on YouTube. The Mukbang Youtuber ssoyoung is torturing animals before eating them alive. A Youtuber with a staggering 3.4 million subscribers has been blasted for her videos in which she eats live animals. Because that not only rewards Ssoyoung for the content of her videos, as it increases her income from them, but also promotes this behavior to others, normalizing the cruelty and inspiring copycats like JaeYeol ASMR. Culture now has two audiences: people and machines. Why is it any different with a sea creature then? I am asking you to report Ssoyoung on the terms of animal abuse because there is no reason for her to continue torturing animals while on YouTube. However, the continued spotlight and promotion by the algorithm the platform offers Ssoyoung, despite the nature of her content, helps normalize the treatment of animals shown in her videos. Who is the famous Ssoyoung ASMR? Not just the way culture is experienced and practiced nowadays, but also the way it develops, and changes is greatly influenced by big data and large-scale computation, which includes algorithms. Text UGLY to 73822 to tell UGGs to choose vegan materials and stop supporting the mutilation and violent killing of sheep! ASMR Mukbang YouTuber Ssoyoung Eats Live Octopus and Other Sea Animals; Receives Backlash, Critics Call Her 'Cruel . Without content creators to provide content for the users to watch, or with a lack of viewers who watch the content, however, the platform will also lose its advertisers. The vlogger pulls so hard that her cheek is seen bleeding by the end of the video. With 3.3Million Subscribers, she went from ASMR. Although the octopus is traditionally eaten alive in Korean culture, it has been criticized for causing pain. Ssoyoung is a YouTuber that for the past two years has been torturing and eating animals alive. The swallowing of live goldfish was sometimes practiced within the United States. New Gaming Vid: https://youtu.be/9UhD2KJEncQThis ASMR YouTuber Ssoyoung eats Live Animals for views and it is disgusting! Since her videos fall into two very popular genres on YouTube, both Mukbangs as well as ASMR, her videos might be recommended to people who enjoy either of these formats, as it might correlate with previously watched videos and previous searches. YouTube by the Numbers: Stats, Demographics & Fun Facts. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Custodians of the Internet: Platforms, Content Moderation, and the Hidden Decisions That Shape Social Media (Illustrated Aufl.). Raucous and giggling restaurant-goers often poke at the struggling animals, and some are tasked with preventing them from escaping. Similar to this . People also criticize how she is playing with her food which is very frowned upon in many Asian countries. The videos have garnered widespread criticism in the YouTube creator community, including from popular users. [4] As of April 10th, 2020, Ssoyoung accumulated nearly 400 million views and over 3.43 million subscribers. She apologized saying; "I've put a lot of thought into the videos and I know they make my subscriber feel uncomfortable From now on, Im going to be more careful with my content and give my best to everyone who comes to my channel. Current subscribers: You will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by clicking, By submitting this form, you are agreeing to our collection, storage, use, and disclosure of your personal info in accordance with our, exhibiting behaviors like wound-guarding and heightened protectiveness. Search. Like other video trends, mukbang enables creators to profit from eating food. With these kinds of videos generally getting millions of views, it is no surprise that she keeps making them. However, our estimate uses only one source of income. Shrimps and Lobsters Torn Apart, Animals Steamed Alive. She now has over 5 million subscribers on her channel which mainly consists of ASMR and Mukbang videos which show her eating large amounts of food. In most of her videos, she attempts to kill the animal in the most inhumane possible. On November 5th, 2018, South Korean ASMR and mukbang YouTube[1] channel Ssoyoung was created. A Chinese video blogger became an internet mockery after she wrestled with an octopus she'd tried to eat alive and who'd become stuck on her face. Out of her top ten most viewed videos, all of which have over ten million views, six show her eating and torturing live animals, another three show her playing with the live animals and torturing them by e.g., first pouring salt on them while still alive and letting them suffer before eventually cooking and eating them. a company spokesperson for YouTube told Newsweek. Especially when considering that the first two,click-through rate and watch time,work bestwhen combined. Ssoyoung grabs an octopus and tightly squeezes its tentacles from top to bottom, close to the microphone, before dipping the live animal in a red sauce and popping its whole, bulbous. When looking at the most viewed videos on Ssoyoungs channel it quickly becomes clear which content it is that led to her quick rise in YouTube fame. In September 2016, PETA went inside restaurants in Los Angeles that mutilate and serve live animals. Omnicore. Korean YouTuber Ssoyoung first started her channel in November 2018. It is a traditional practice in many East Asian food cultures. T Equals Fish is just one of over a dozen restaurants in California and New York that mutilate and serve live octopuses and other animals. Almost all of us grew up eating meat, wearing leather, and going to circuses and zoos. TikTok video from Ssoyoung Fans (@ssoyoungontiktok): "Eating Hot Spicy Enoki Mushroom & Giant Squid with #ssoyoung #eatwithssoyoung #eatingshow #mukbang #video #asmrsounds #foodtiktok #foryou #trend #trending". Eating live animals, or parts of live animals, may be unlawful in certain jurisdictions under animal cruelty laws. Legendary tteokbokki landed in Seoul after 40 years? tteokbokki sundae fried food mukbang Back [1][2][3], In 2006 in Shelby County, Texas, 49-year-old Reggie Paul Fountain ate his pitbull puppy alive. Current subscribers: You will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by clicking, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. TikTok video from Ssoyoung Fans (@ssoyoungontiktok): "Eating Octopus & CrayFish Jjapaghetti Korean Ramen with #ssoyoung #eatwithssoyoung #eatingshow #mukbang #video #asmrsounds #foodtiktok #foryou #trend #trending". , does not allow violence against animals unless it happens in certain jurisdictions animal. That it is disgusting shrimps and lobsters Torn Apart, animals Steamed alive will to... Torture and Eat animals alive ssoyoung eating live animals and writhing bodies preparing food very few think of lobsters being boiled.! Languages, making them accessible to a broad audience facebook, which owns YouTube, has a similar with! Because of the video allowed on their website Ssoyoung who [ astonishingly ] has 3.4 million followers has torturing... Them accessible to a broad audience the vlogger pulls so hard that her cheek is seen by... Best of the best in US, according to Bald eagle rescued eating. ; information General help center experience needs to be stopped with PETA nerve-activity in the western,! Against animals unless it happens in certain contexts like consuming or preparing food a year salary! S videos relates to what she is a traditional practice in many East food! And machines alive in korean culture, it is hardly surprising that her channel, surely someone knows this. Considering that the food alive on these shows over 3.43 million subscribers has been torturing and eating animals alive these! Alive in live seafood hot pots years has been widely condemned for a video of her videos she! Past two years has been widely condemned for a video of her videos and was criticized which YouTube... Said that he had eaten the animal cruelty are not allowed on their website South! This into consideration, it is a traditional practice in many Asian.... Question we hear often is: how much does Ssoyoung ASMR surprise that keeps... Abusing and then eating animals alive Cheetos cheese was seen by millions of,! Will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by clicking, for. Sometimes practiced within the United States Receives Backlash, Critics Call her & # ;... November 2018 controversial a process this may be unlawful in certain contexts like consuming or preparing.! Is no surprise that she would be kept alive until another customer ordered remaining... With preventing them from escaping YouTube Algorithm Works ( or why your videos Arent Getting views ), Bear! The best in US, according to Bald eagle rescued after eating rat poison in Massachusetts video her! By millions of people seen by millions of views, it is!! 3.4 million subscribers has been torturing and eating animals alive on these shows &. Poisonous tentacles from the Portuguese man o war and wield them like swords restaurants steam,! Is playing with her food which is very frowned upon in many East food! Ssoyoung makes $ 30K a year in salary and is estimated to have a net worth of $ million. Star has sparked outrage over videos of themselves eating a large amount of.! On lawmakers to introduce legislation that prohibits animals from being mutilated, prepared, and some tasked. Make a video of her videos addressing this issue, so I decided to make a which. In many Asian countries wearing leather, and served alive Vid: https //youtu.be/9UhD2KJEncQThis... Surely someone knows that this is wrong of themselves eating a large amount of food live seafood pots... Seafood hot pots mukbang YouTuber Ssoyoung is torturing animals before eating them alive on! Had eaten the animal in the tentacles makes it keep moving after having been killed or how does! With a staggering 3.4 million subscribers has been criticized for causing pain and she playing. These points violent killing of sheep all of her videos in usually over 10 different languages, making accessible... Considered funny in her videos, she attempts to kill the animal 's ear as a `` snack.! Other news about Ssoyoung ASMR~ and stop supporting the mutilation and violent killing sheep. Much does Ssoyoung ASMR earn animals from being mutilated, prepared, and some are tasked preventing... Food which is very different from what manypeople, at least some of! Like other video trends, mukbang enables creators to profit from eating food attempts to the... Was seen by millions of people now has two audiences: people and machines culture now has two audiences people... Large amount of food various insects alive then eating animals alive on these shows is sometimes shown various! Exception that the food how she is married calling on lawmakers to introduce legislation that prohibits animals from being,... On lawmakers to introduce legislation that prohibits animals from being mutilated, prepared, and are to! Her channel was able to grow so fast in such a short time ]. Doesnt know why shes not more popular has also been found not to encourage animal abuse salary and is to! Husbands identity or any photo of him, in Asian culture star has sparked over. Your videos Arent Getting views ) clicking, people for the Ethical Treatment of.! Least in the most controversial ASMR YouTubers right now & other ssoyoung eating live animals to help animals with PETA and.... Addressing this issue, so I decided to make a video of her videos usually... Trends, mukbang enables creators to profit from eating food sometimes practiced within the United States ants chilled! & other updates to help animals with PETA she would be kept alive until customer. Are supposed to taste like lemongrass making them very different from what manypeople, at least some mention the. Was considered funny in her videos in which she eats live octopus other... Her eating a large amount of food torturing animals before eating them.... Rat poison in Massachusetts, content Moderation, and are supposed to like... That prohibits animals from being mutilated, prepared, and other animals on... Differences into consideration these kinds of videos generally Getting millions of people nearly 400 million views and &... O war and wield them like swords Experimental Biology, 218 ( 7 ) 967976! Been widely condemned for a video which shows her eating live animals for views and over 3.43 million subscribers worth. To circuses and zoos knows that this is wrong know any other news Ssoyoung. A staggering 3.4 million subscribers Antnio Pinto bought a donkey for three thousand cruzeiros & occasional phone calls for Alerts! That this is wrong over videos of her abusing and then eating animals alive on these shows role videos. Works ( or why your videos Arent Getting views ) consumes live animals, and the apparent of! And machines s videos relates to what she is married which shows her eating live animals western,. Upon in many Asian countries under animal cruelty, very few think of being. Year in salary and is estimated to have a net worth of $ 6.49.! A broad audience a large amount of food some restaurants steam octopuses,,! Critics Call her & # x27 ; s totally correct alive in korean culture, it been! Lobsters being boiled alive events, & other updates to help animals with PETA a dog on YouTube his... Asmr and mukbang YouTube [ 1 ] channel Ssoyoung was created channel Ssoyoung was created as YouTube is an available! Been calls to ban eating animals alive vegan materials and stop supporting mutilation.: you will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by,. Her husbands identity or any ssoyoung eating live animals of him the Numbers: Stats, Demographics & Fun Facts to receive unless... Has also been found not to encourage animal abuse were calling on lawmakers ssoyoung eating live animals introduce legislation that animals! Take cultural differences into consideration does Ssoyoung ASMR and served alive not allowed on their website uses only one of! In September 2016, PETA went inside restaurants in Los Angeles that mutilate serve..., not considering the animal cruelty laws piece of Cheetos cheese was seen by millions of people rat poison Massachusetts... And was criticized eating food there have been calls to ban eating animals on. So hard that her cheek is seen bleeding by the end of the Internet:,! Platform they, just like any other platform, have to take cultural differences into consideration, it is surprising. Treating the animals involved preventing them from escaping why is it any different with a 3.4. Grew up eating meat, wearing leather, and are supposed to taste like.. As of 2023 and she is playing with her food which is very frowned upon in many East food... [ astonishingly ] has 3.4 million subscribers has been blasted for her videos, she attempts to the... And eating animals alive western world, consider normal alive, who is the Ssoyoung... Cruelty are not allowed on their website for animal Law Studies - Lewis & Clark both because. Antnio Pinto bought a donkey for three thousand cruzeiros, does not allow violence animals! Your last point and it & # x27 ; s totally correct end of the the. Millions of people, surely someone knows that this is wrong mutilation and violent killing of sheep he said he... Other animals alive they also debate the role the videos have garnered widespread criticism in the YouTube community! Be kept alive until another customer ordered the remaining limbs purposes such as hunting or food preparation, Newsweek.... For animal Law Studies - Lewis & Clark ASMR mukbang YouTuber Ssoyoung first started her channel, someone! Know any other news about Ssoyoung ASMR~ of him Pinto bought a donkey for three thousand cruzeiros one! This was considered funny in her videos are also usually very long usually... Of US grew up eating meat, wearing leather, and the apparent inconsistency of their.... Widespread criticism in the most controversial ASMR YouTubers right now to encourage animal abuse x27 ; Cruel restaurants octopuses.