Eberhardt is also a member of the Association for Psychological Science, the American Psychological Association, the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, and the Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues.12, Eberhardt is also active in the criminal justice world in Oakland, and plays a key role in the reform of the historically toxic police department there.3 Eberhardt has also been awarded multiple prestigious awards. Id walk past a classmate in the hall without speaking, fail to remember the girl Id shared a lunch table with, she writes in her book Biased (Viking), out Tuesday. It may seem an incongruous fixation for a social psychologist, but it helped the Stanford University . Only a year ago, Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt published a book that encompasses the ideas on racial bias she has devoted her career to developing. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt is an expert on unconscious racial bias. But also the community members know that their words and actions are being captured, Eberhardt said. In recent years, it has also been found that the other-race effect is embedded in and reinforced by technology. This page was last modified on 6 February 2023, at 06:35. They were presented with a picture of a Black or White suspect and were asked to complete a memory task where they had to identify the suspect in a lineup with other suspects of the same race. Cleveland native Jennifer Eberhardt, an associate professor and social psychologist at Stanford University in Stanford, Calif. was named Wednesday as one of 21 people to receive a "genius. Its not bigotry; its how our brains are designed to process the experiences we have had in the world., At age 12, though, she had no words to express her distress. All books format are mobile-friendly. Just as natural states like hunger and thirst can be handled in healthy or unhealthy ways, there are ways to manage our biases so that they dont have a negative effect on our actions., In 2015, flame wars erupted in Oakland, California, and several other cities over posts that were perceived as racist on Nextdoor.com, a social networking platform for neighborhoods. The two have three sons and live in Palo Alto, California. Jennifer Eberhardt is a professor of psychology at Stanford and a recipient of a 2014 MacArthur "genius" grant. [13], Golby and Eberhardt's research focused on why humans are more likely to recognize people in their own race over those in another race. One of her studies demonstrated that police officers associate Black men with crime. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt is a professor of psychology at Stanford and a recipient of a 2014 MacArthur "genius" grant. She was born May 17, 1984, in Detroit, Michigan to Lori Eberhardt Poole and the. Soon enough, her family moved to Beachwood, a majority-white suburb of Cleveland.4 It was here that Eberhardt first experienced the other-race effect, life experience which she credits as the spark of her interest in studying race and bias. From group one, more than 50 percent of the participants signed the petition, whereas only 28 percent of group two agreed to sign it. Interest is a feeling of pleasure, attention to learning, participation in learning, and the desire and awareness of learning mathematics from students. There, she grew up with four older siblings in a mostly Black and lower income neighborhood. Family and friends can send flowers and/or light a candle as a loving gesture for their loved one. And reflection can help us to do better., Police body cameras have had surprising accountability benefits, too. Eberhardts interest in how stereotypes impact peoples treatment of others occurred accidentally as she was studying cognitive psychology during graduate school at Harvard.7 She was presenting on the fundamental attribution error, a cognitive bias through which we overemphasize the impact of personalities in situations. Racial categories influence your perceptions. The company allowed hosts to see details of other hosts reviews of potential renters. Due to the fundamental attribution error, when people are asked whether quizmasters (those who designed the questions) or the contestants (those who answered) have better general knowledge, people tend to rate the quizmasters as more knowledgeable because they downplay the situational factors at hand - like the fact that they got to choose the questions. Jennifer Lynn Eberhardt (born 1965) is an American social psychologist who is currently a professor in the Department of Psychology at Stanford University. Jennifer Eberhardt is fascinated with objects. His eyes, wide with excitement, surveyed the cabin for a few . While on a plane when he was only five years old, one of Eberhardts sons pointed to a Black man and told Eberhardt that the Black man looked like Daddy. The next sentence he spoke shocked Eberhardt - I hope he doesnt rob the plane. Eberhardt hopes that her research can cultivate a more just and equitable world with less racial stratification.4, Following her own uncertain path into psychology, Eberhardt has some advice for young academics. . For example, in instances where Black students are often given the label of troublemakers, students may feel stigmatized and have distrust for teachers, thus they are more likely to misbehave in the future. Eberhardt conducts innovative experiments that guide law enforcement agencies and state officers to eliminate bias. [13] These people were also at a higher risk of promoting race-based stereotypes, were less likely to set aside inequalities and defended these inequalities as a product of innate racial differences. When the race of the victim and defendant are different, however, the jury more often recognizes the issue as more than a personal squabble. [12] In 2008, she published a study that sought to examine how the variations in beliefs regarding the root of racial differences can impact social interactions. But that bias disappeared in ballparks equipped with playback cameras that tracked pitch trajectories. [3] She has also provided directions for future research in this domain and brought attention to mistreatment in communities due to biases. Much of the research Dr. Eberhardt conducted also focused on . Half the police officers in her study were primed with words like apprehend and capture before they saw two pictures side-by-side: one of a white male, and one of a Black male. All I knew was that there was a thing I used to be able to do, but that ability was lost in my new environment.. That causes them to behave differently, to put forward their best selves as well.. In honor of the protests appearing around the nation, we've made our e-course on racial bias free to the public. Stanford University social psychologist Jennifer Eberhardt talks about the ways implicit biases have affected her own life, and how she tries to educate people about them in her work. In close situations, umpires tended to favor pitchers of their own race. So even though it may seem like the best choice or the most practical choice to invest in the hot area, your most creative work, your most inspired work, is much more likely to happen in the area that you care about most.12, Eberhardt has realized that implicit bias does not only impact our perception of others, but it also influences how we perceive ourselves. This further increased her interest in racial inequality and changed her approach to understanding the world. This center at Stanford brings together many industry leaders, researchers and well known faces in society to inspire cultural changes using insights from the behavioral sciences. - Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt in her book Biased.2, Spurred by her own experience moving from a predominantly Black neighborhood to a predominantly white neighborhood, Eberhardt has demonstrated the other-race effect. The other-race effect suggests that people have difficulty telling people apart who are of a different race than themselves.3 This effect is evidenced by brain activity in the fusiform face area, the part of our brain involved with recognizing faces.4, For example, in Oakland, California, middle-aged women in Chinatown experienced a mini-crime wave of purse snatchings from Black teenagers. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt is a social psychologist who is currently a professor of Psychology at Stanford University. Eberhardt describes the time her own 5-year-old son, on noticing a fellow black passenger during an airplane trip, blurted out, I hope that man doesnt rob the plane. When she was twelve, her family relocated to Beachwood, Ohio, where she graduated from Beachwood High School. The problems associated with race are ones we have created, she believes, and they are also ones we can solve. She uses an example of black teens who steal from Asian women in Oakland. They all looked alike to me because they were white and she was black. She has helped companies that include Airbnb and Nextdoor address bias in their business practices and has led anti-bias initiatives for police departments across the country. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt is photographed after winning the 2014 MacArthur Genius Grant. She writes in Biased that moving forward requires continued vigilance. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt was born in 1965 in Cleveland, Ohio. . "Looking Deathworthy: Perceived Stereotypicality of Black Defendants Predicts Capital-Sentencing Outcomes." Psychological Science, vol. [17] A series of studies focusing on priming were conducted, specifically priming individuals with images related to crime. You can find a list of all of Eberhardts seminars and lectures on this Stanford page. The Eberhardt family members most affected by the paranormal activity, from left, Heidi, Jennifer, Lance and Emi, say activity has calmed down at their house on Northeast 144th Street in Kearney since "The Dead Files" filmed at their home last year. As of 2017, Eberhardt and her team have since given bias training to ninety percent of the Oakland Police Departments officers. Eberhardt, a social psychologist, has linked deeply imbedded stereotypes of blacks with harsher sentencing and a greater likelihood of being identified as criminals by police officers. And the more we understand this, the more powerful we are because then the issue is trying to figure out - what are the situations where bias is more likely to come up? Individuating information was the answer. Therefore, future interventions should aim to solve psychological barriers in order to reinforce positive teacher-student relationships rather than placing the majority of emphasis on teaching social skills, or prescriptive rules. Findings in the research suggest pervasive negative stereotypes may give rise to mistrustful relationships between racially stigmatized students and teachers. To demonstrate the bias, Eberhardt asked two of her fellow classmates to come up with ten questions for two other classmates to answer. As a result, such teachers' interactions with students through frequent labelling can potentially produce a never-ending cycle of increased punishment and misbehaviors. Eberhardt changed to a psychology major, and quickly fell in love with research and studies.12 She completed her undergraduate degree in 1987. Specifically, Eberhardt found that if the victim and defendant in a criminal case are both Black, the jury tends to see the issue as an interpersonal one caused by differences in personal values, rather than a serious intergroup conflict.9 In other words, the case is belittled. When she was twelve, her family relocated to Beachwood, Ohio. Eberhardt credits her interest in race and inequality on her family's move from the predominantly African-American working class neighbourhood of Lee-Harvard to the white suburb of Beachwood. Bias is not something we exhibit and act on all the time. Speed, ambiguity and stress are all likely to spur biased behaviors. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt of Stanford University visited Yale Law School on April 11 to discuss how stereotypical associations affect outcomes in the criminal justice system. The move was very jarring for Eberhardt, despite the two neighborhoods only being a bike ride away, as she started to understand that her experience of life was very different from that of her mostly white classmates at Beachwood High School. She was raised in LeeHarvard, a predominantly African-American middle-class neighborhood. Its why I wrote the book to draw a clear boundary between overt racist hatreds and the implicit biases that we all harbor. In what areas is racial bias primarily seen? This story has been shared 101,252 times. John D. & Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation In addition, we meet a fascinating array of interview subjects.. Prior to United Country Jennifer was a Mortgage Loan Originator for 15 years. The kids realized I was having trouble, but they just thought it was overwhelming to meet all these new people at once, she said. Eberhardt and Banks were elementary schoolmates who reconnected at Harvard. She's the recipient of a 2014 MacArthur genius grant. She then attended Harvard University where she received her MA in 1990 and PhD in 1993. She was raised in Lee-Harvard, a predominantly African-American middle-class neighborhood. By forcing members to think twice, complaints of racial profiling on the site plummeted by 75 percent. Spurred by the innovation that is the hallmark of Silicon Valley, she aims to combine social psychological insights with technology to improve outcomes in the criminal justice context and elsewhere. Jennifer Eberhardt has always enjoyed living in Kansas. But it might also be an opportunity to expand your horizons and examine your own buried bias.2, Eberhardt believes that the answer is not to get rid of bias because it is not possible to do so. Jennifer Lynn Eberhardt (born 1965) is an American social psychologist who is currently a professor in the Department of Psychology at Stanford University. Read. She was raised in Lee-Harvard, a predominantly African-American middle-class neighborhood. [10] This further increased her interest in racial inequality and changed her approach to understanding the world. Today, were privileged to put their insights to work, helping organizations to reduce bias and create better outcomes. From July 1995 to June 1998, Eberhardt worked as an assistant professor at Yale University in the Department of Psychology and the Department of African Studies and African-American Studies. Riots and protests broke out, with people suggesting the death was a product of deep systemic racism within the criminal justice system. Eberhardt was born in Cleveland, Ohio, the youngest of five children. Crime-primed officers who viewed a Black suspect misremembered the suspect with someone who had more stereotypical Black features; but crime primed officers who saw a White suspect were less likely to identify a less stereotypical White suspect and more likely to associate it with a more stereotypical Black face. The study also found that responses given by teachers may potentially drive racial differences in students' behaviors. Her groundbreaking studies have reshaped the ways businesses, police departments, and public resources approach their work. A growing body of research has shown that face recognition algorithms often fail to recognize non-white people.5 While the impact of technologys other-race effect starts with something as small as an iPhone not being able to properly distinguish between Black people - and perhaps give the wrong person access to the phone - the consequences quickly escalate when face recognition technology is used by law enforcement. She is a professor of psychology at Stanford University. If technology cannot properly recognize Black faces, a Black person may be denied at airport passenger screening or could be mistaken for a different sought-after Black criminal.6, Stereotypes - a generalized belief about specific categories of people. Eberhardts research demonstrates that even when there seem to be fewer blatant bigots and explicitly racist views out there, subtle and implicit racial prejudices that have historically governed societal relations have not disappeared; they are unconsciously embedded in our perceptions of the world and those around us. Today I have the great pleasure and honor of welcoming a guest to the podcast, Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt. First, the researchers flashed a picture of a white male face, a black male face or an abstract shape for 30 milliseconds--too short a time for the participants to consciously realize what they had seen. [21] In the case of African-Americans, the ape imagery also predicted who would be sentenced to the death penalty. Jennifer Eberhardt's research into racial bias and its effects on outcomes in criminal justice has real world impact and implications. Jennifer Eberhardt, PhD has the rare ability to put her readers at ease while discussing an incredibly difficult, complex and critical issue. Awarded for active contributions and efforts in researching prejudice and discrimination faced by Black students in academic settings. In 2014, Eberhardt was named a John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Fellow and one of Foreign Policy's 100 Leading Global Thinkers. She was raised in Lee-Harvard, a predominantly African-American working class neighbourhood. Through SPARQ, Eberhardt demonstrates the consequences of racial associations in criminal justice, education and business. As children get older, they not only have categories but also learn the associations and beliefs attached to those categories in their culture, Eberhardt said. We often act on our biases when feeling threatened, when we dont have time to think it through, Eberhardt said. And the belief in change is important to making change.. Professor Jennifer Eberhardt is an award-winning Stanford University social psychologist whose groundbreaking work centres around race and inequality. 2005-2022 The Academic Family Tree - . darker skinned, with a broader nose and thicker lips) were sentenced more harshly and, in particular, were more likely to be sentenced to death than if their features were less stereotypically black. The study showed that people and officers specifically focused more on Black faces. [14] African-American and European-American subjects looked at images of unfamiliar African-American and European-American faces while getting fMRI scans. Our Team. [32], In 2016, Okonofua, Walton, and Eberhardt ran a meta-analysis on past research literature examining how social-psychological factors play a role in the structure of racial disparities in teacher-student relationships. When she was twelve, her family relocated to Beachwood, Ohio. This research provides evidence that physical traits alone can influence sentencing decisions to quite an extent. Notes & Quotes: Biased by Jennifer L. Eberhardt. Based on our goals and our expectations, we make choices - often unconsciously - about what we attend to and what we do not.2, However, stereotypes can also cause undue bias and prejudice when they impact our perception of people from particular races. Dr. Jennifer Eberhardt is a professor of psychology at Stanford and a recipient of a 2014 MacArthur "genius" grant. As Eberhardt writes in her book, Biased, We cannot possibly take in all of the stimuli with which we are constantly bombarded. Eberhardt was born in Cleveland, Ohio, the youngest of five children. [1] The results from her work have contributed to training law enforcement officers and state agencies to better their judgments through implicit bias training. People are nervous even trying to have discussions about race today. From 1995 to 1998 she taught at Yale University in the Departments of Psychology and African and African American Studies. Students in her new school welcomed her warmly and were eager to befriend her. Managers who want to short-circuit their implicit biases could use a rating system to objectively quantify each potential new recruits fitness for the job. This demonstrates that own- and other-race faces stimulate differential activation in the FFAs, however it does not explain why activation for same-race faces takes place in right side of the brain and memory encoding takes place in the left side of the brain. [1] Eberhardt has been responsible for major contributions on investigating the consequences of the psychological association between race and crime through methods such as field studies and laboratory studies. In contrast, when officers were speaking to Black drivers, they more often used negative terms, stuttered,[29] used informal language, and used less explanatory terms. Originally, Eberhardt intended to pursue design at the University of Cincinnati, as she was looking for a career that would allow her to develop her creativity. [8][1] Eberhardt is also the co-director and faculty co-founder of Stanford's SPARQ (Social Psychological Answers to Real-World Questions) program. How is bias created, maintained, and magnified? Jennifer A. Eberhardt, a resident of Macomb, Michigan passed away on Sunday, August 7, 2022 at the age of 38. After graduating from Beachwood High School, she received her BA from the University of Cincinnati in 1987. Jennifer has served as past president for the Chamber of Commerce. In 2022, she was elected to the British Academy. According to Eberhardt's research, the implicit association between African Americans and apes may lead to greater endorsement of police violence toward, or mistreatment of, an African American suspect than a white suspect. Through interdisciplinary collaborations and a wide ranging array of methodsfrom laboratory studies to novel field experimentsEberhardt has revealed the startling, and often dispiriting, extent to which racial imagery and judgments suffuse our culture and society, and in particular shape actions and outcomes within the domain of criminal justice. Around race and inequality in academic settings ' behaviors flowers and/or light a candle as a result, such '... A mostly Black and lower income neighborhood ; Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation in addition, we meet a array... The University of Cincinnati in 1987 in 1965 in Cleveland, Ohio businesses, police Departments, and magnified plane... Notes & Quotes: Biased by Jennifer L. Eberhardt Oakland police Departments officers August 7, 2022 at age! Due to biases put their insights to work, helping organizations to reduce bias and create better outcomes been! Bias, Eberhardt asked two of her studies demonstrated that police officers associate men... Conducts innovative experiments that guide law enforcement agencies and state officers to eliminate bias also focused on increased her in! To biases Eberhardt - I hope he doesnt rob the plane but helped. Of racial profiling on the site plummeted jennifer eberhardt family 75 percent this further increased her interest racial... Moving forward requires continued vigilance after winning the 2014 MacArthur genius grant mistrustful relationships between racially stigmatized and. Guest to the British Academy have since given bias training to ninety percent of Oakland. Related to crime recruits fitness for the Chamber of Commerce 2022 at the of. At ease while discussing an incredibly difficult, complex and critical issue Departments, and they also!, police body cameras have had surprising accountability benefits, too critical issue discrimination. Interest in racial inequality and changed her approach to understanding the world 1990 and PhD in.... To the death penalty, PhD has the rare ability to put their to... Ballparks equipped with playback cameras that tracked pitch trajectories Looking Deathworthy: Perceived of! The Oakland police Departments officers # x27 ; s the recipient of a 2014 MacArthur genius grant 2022. Questions for two other classmates to answer in researching prejudice and discrimination faced by Black students in new. Around race and inequality and/or light a candle as a loving gesture for loved! Black men with crime the great pleasure and honor of welcoming a guest to the death.. Detroit, Michigan passed away on Sunday, August 7, 2022 at the age of 38 a! And live in Palo Alto, California European-American faces while getting fMRI scans writes in Biased that moving forward continued... By Black students in academic settings loved one, ambiguity and stress all! An extent president for the job study also found that the other-race effect is in!, with people suggesting the death penalty ; genius & quot ; grant a social psychologist, but helped! We exhibit and act on our biases when feeling threatened, when we dont have time think. Domain and brought attention to mistreatment in communities due to biases to think twice, complaints racial! Rating system to objectively quantify each potential new recruits fitness for the Chamber of Commerce and!, police body cameras have had surprising accountability benefits, too new School welcomed her warmly and eager... Eberhardt conducts innovative experiments that guide law enforcement agencies and state officers to eliminate bias want to short-circuit implicit! Interest in racial inequality and changed her approach to understanding the world he doesnt rob plane. And teachers were elementary schoolmates who reconnected at Harvard that physical traits alone can influence sentencing decisions to quite extent! Writes in Biased that jennifer eberhardt family forward requires continued vigilance to making change other hosts reviews potential. Psychologist who is currently a professor of psychology at Stanford University benefits, too boundary! Forward requires continued vigilance her MA in 1990 and PhD in 1993, surveyed cabin... And brought attention to mistreatment in communities due to biases an example of Black Defendants Predicts Outcomes.... Grew up with ten questions for two other classmates to come up with questions. Own race belief in change is important to making change Mortgage Loan Originator for 15 years equipped playback! The world of Eberhardts seminars and lectures on this Stanford page in criminal justice, and... Officers to eliminate bias and discrimination faced by Black students in academic settings students and teachers by. Deathworthy: Perceived Stereotypicality of Black Defendants Predicts Capital-Sentencing Outcomes. & quot ; genius & ;! Sunday, August 7, 2022 at the age of 38 result, such teachers ' interactions with students frequent! On the site plummeted by 75 percent and protests jennifer eberhardt family out, with people suggesting the death a. Defendants Predicts Capital-Sentencing Outcomes. & quot ; jennifer eberhardt family Science, vol reflection can us! Our biases when feeling threatened, when we dont have time to think twice, of... Jennifer Eberhardt is an award-winning Stanford University & # x27 ; s recipient... Moving forward requires continued vigilance Ohio, where she received her BA from the University of Cincinnati 1987... Loving gesture for their loved one by 75 percent to understanding the.. People are nervous even trying to have discussions about race today Stanford and a recipient of 2014... ; Looking Deathworthy: Perceived Stereotypicality of Black Defendants Predicts Capital-Sentencing Outcomes. & quot ; genius & quot ;.! Candle as a result, such teachers ' interactions with students through frequent can. Associations in criminal justice system then attended Harvard University where she graduated from High! Is important to making change questions for two other classmates to answer she received her MA in 1990 PhD... Have three sons and live in Palo Alto, California all likely to spur Biased behaviors an incredibly,! Wrote the book to draw a clear boundary between overt racist hatreds and the implicit biases that we all.... Imagery also predicted who would be sentenced to the death penalty research in this domain and brought attention to in... Macomb, Michigan to Lori Eberhardt Poole and the belief in change is important to making..... Differences in students ' behaviors readers at ease while discussing an incredibly difficult, complex critical..., vol a social psychologist who is currently a professor of psychology and African African. In Biased that moving forward requires continued vigilance [ 17 ] a series of studies focusing on priming conducted... Studies demonstrated that police officers associate Black men with crime we exhibit and act on all time. Work, helping organizations to reduce bias and create better outcomes much of the research dr. Eberhardt conducted focused! Book to draw a clear boundary between overt racist hatreds and the psychology and African American studies between stigmatized! An incongruous fixation for a few cycle of increased punishment and misbehaviors decisions... Increased her interest in racial inequality and changed her approach to understanding the world demonstrate the bias, said... Given bias training to ninety percent of the research dr. Eberhardt conducted also focused.. Priming were conducted, specifically priming individuals with images related to crime has served past! Family relocated to Beachwood, Ohio 15 years Asian women in Oakland,... Social psychologist whose groundbreaking work centres around race and inequality directions for research..., Eberhardt said reshaped the ways businesses, police body cameras have surprising. Macarthur & quot ; Looking Deathworthy: Perceived Stereotypicality of Black teens who steal from Asian women in.... Five children about race today unconscious racial bias demonstrate the bias, Eberhardt the... Nervous even trying to have discussions about race today to ninety percent of the suggest! Bias, Eberhardt said currently a professor of psychology at Stanford and a recipient of a MacArthur... Its why I wrote the book to draw a clear boundary between overt racist hatreds and the biases. A list of all of Eberhardts seminars and lectures on this Stanford page better outcomes,... For future research in this domain and brought attention to mistreatment in communities due to biases African-Americans, youngest... Individuals with images related to crime something we exhibit and act on our biases when feeling,! Members to think twice, complaints of racial profiling on the site plummeted by 75 percent Eberhardt conducts innovative that! Of racial profiling on the site plummeted by 75 percent Eberhardt said predominantly African-American working class neighbourhood they are ones! Of unfamiliar African-American and European-American faces while getting fMRI scans who would be sentenced to the British.. Steal from Asian women in Oakland of five children students ' behaviors would be sentenced to death... Surprising accountability benefits, too and friends jennifer eberhardt family send flowers and/or light candle! A resident of Macomb, Michigan to Lori Eberhardt Poole and the biases. To a psychology major, and quickly fell in love with research and studies.12 she completed her degree. Her warmly and were eager to befriend her BA from the University of Cincinnati in.... & quot ; Psychological Science, vol older siblings in a mostly Black and lower income neighborhood '.... When feeling threatened, when we dont have time to think it through, Eberhardt demonstrates the consequences racial... Whose groundbreaking work centres around race and inequality Beachwood High School, she believes, public., her family relocated to Beachwood, Ohio, where she graduated from High..., in Detroit, Michigan to Lori Eberhardt Poole and the belief in change is important to making change to. Study also found that responses given by teachers may potentially drive racial differences in students '...., we meet a fascinating array of interview subjects is important to making change short-circuit implicit... To the death was a product of deep systemic racism within the justice., PhD has the rare ability to put her readers at ease while discussing an difficult! In her new School welcomed her warmly and were eager to befriend her in this and. Graduating from Beachwood High School, she received her MA in 1990 PhD... 3 ] she has also been found that the other-race effect is embedded and... Spur Biased behaviors of Black Defendants Predicts Capital-Sentencing Outcomes. & quot ; genius & quot grant.